The concept of the rule of law by courtney taylor hamara, b. The framers of the constitution were well familiar with the postulates of rule of law as propounded by dicey and as modified in its application to british india. A thesis submitted to the school of graduate studies in partial fulfillment of the requirements. Legal theorists have called it an essentially contested concept. Law on organizing this symposium on the subject of the rule of. The rule of law is an important political ideal, which has achieved unprecedented support. Albert venn dicey and the principles of the rule of law. The principle of reciprocity is therefore integral to the rule of law concept in both rule book theories and in rightsbased theories. Introduction i have written extensively about the rule of law for two basic reasons. The concept of the rule of law does not, in and of itself, speak to the notion of justice. The significance of the rule of law and its implications for the european union and the united states article pdf available may 2010 with 2,688 reads how we measure reads. The rule of law stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The concept and the rule of law by jeremy waldron ssrn.
Laws must be prospective in nature so that the effect of the law may only take place after the law has been passed. It places this analysis against a background of more theoretical accounts of the idea of the rule of law, drawing in ideas of. The rule of law is a concept that describes the supreme authority of the law over. A test applied to determine whether a person accused of a crime was sane at the time of its commission and, therefore, criminally responsible for the wrongdoing. The origins of the rule of law, 11 tracing the history of the concept of the rule of law through many centuries. Starting with the greek and then the roman philosophers, the british philosophers, and the french enlightenment, hayek identified from these writings the ideas represented by the words the rule of law. Introduction the rule of law is one of the most important political ideals of our time. In the present post, we shall discuss the difference between rule by law and rule of law. In india, the concept of rule of law can be traced back to the upanishad. Trebilcock and daniels 2008ii refer to such definitions as thick and thin, respectively.
Absence of arbitrary is the soul of the rule of law. The concept of law is the most important and original work of legal philosophy written this century. A definition of the rule of law for deployed judge advocates. But without a clear definition, the rule of law is in danger of coming to mean. The historical formation of human rights 4047 fordham 20. Additionally, within the united states, several state and local jurisdictions exist, each having. Fuller and the morality that makes law possible jj 1. See, for example, jorgen moller and svenderik skaaning, the rule of law. Rule of law international journal of law and legal.
In europe and the united states, the idea of the rule of law hereinafter referred. No person should be suffered except for the breach of law. This book analyses the concept of the rule of law in the context of international law, through the case law of the european court of human rights. Questi ons are though raised as to the extent to which the constitutional promise of the rule of law matches with actual situation in india. I shall use the phrase the florida debacle to refer to. It investigates how the court has defined and interpreted the notion of the rule of law in its jurisprudence. Known as harts most famous work, the concept of law emerged from a set of lectures that hart began to deliver in 1952 in which he developed a sophisticated view of legal positivism. Concept release on harmonization of securities offering. Edward coke is said to be the originator of concept of rule of law when he said that the king must be under god and law and thus vindicated the supremacy of law over the pretensions of the executives. Indeed, a large literature grapples with the rule of law as a concept. Rule of law is, of course, a concept that is inevitably.
It concludes with a brief description of some of the criticisms that have been made about the concept of the rule of law. Definitions, measures, patterns and causes, 14 palgrave macmillan 2014. This essay deals with the essential elements of the rule of law concept that underlie present day legal research in the european union eu. The concept of law hla hart, herbert lionel adolphus hart. The rule of law as a constitutional principle of the. Two concepts of the rule of law dietze, gottfried on. In india, the concept of rule of law can be traced back to the upanishads. The salient features of rule of law as enumerated by prof. Under this concept of the rule of law, the state must act in accordance with the laws it has. Origins sa law can be traced back to roman law, romandutch law and english law. Rule of law practitioners around the world have relied on this handbook for almost five years now. The rule of law comprises a number of principles of a formal and.
The rule of law as a concept in constitutional discourse jstor. After defining the notion of rule of law, it explains some elements of the concept in a succinct manner and concludes with some final remarks. The concept of the rule of law and the european court of. The history and elements of the rule of law 233 three themes that course through discussions of the rule of law. The inclusion of certain social and moral values in the concept of rule of. The rule of law of the federal government in the united states is composed of many different sources of law, including constitutional law, statutory law, rules and regulations promulgated by administrative agencies, federal common law, and treaties. This paper first asserts that the rule of law can be accurately described as a common principle. The concept of the rule of law mcmaster university. This section deals with the fields of law in a general way. However, it is possible to draw on general and more precise or minimalist definitions of this term. The purpose of the workshop was to identify the challenges that confront african union au member states with respect to the rule. In fact, it consists of many fields of law that sometimes exhibit large differences. Instead of neatly separated levels of regulation private, local, national, interstate, a congeries of different actors and different layers together form a variegated global administrative space that.
Dicey, introduction to the study of the law of the constitution 181205. Rule by law simply means rule by any law which is laid down by the supreme law making authority of that country. The concept of law in global administrative law 25 governance can usefully be analysed as administration. For example, the court cannot convict a person of a crime committed before a criminal statute prohibiting the conduct was passed. Second, it disregards the very existence of other rol traditions. The rule of law is a concept that resonates across borders and boundaries. The entire base of administrative law rests on the concept of the rule of law. On one hand, it means that no person or government is above the law. Fuller states that all persons, including government officials shall abide by the laws, laws must be prospective. Essential elements of the rule of law concept in the eu. It is entirely possible, particularly in modern dictatorships, that there is a rule of law that is unjust.
The concept of rule of law is of old origin and is an ancient ideal. In modern day as well, the scheme of the indian constitution is based upon the concept of rule of law. The rule of law is seen as a fragile but crucial ideal, and one that is appropriately invoked whenever governments try to get their way by arbitrary and oppressive action or by shortcircuiting the norms and procedures laid down in their countries laws or constitution. The rule of law as a constitutional principle of the european union. In most of the dictatorships and monarchies, there is a set of laws through which the justice is administered. Thus, in development discourse, outside the much narrower world of rule of law practitioners and scholars across different disciplines, the understanding of rule of law is extraordinarily patchy. It is also seen as an integral part of good governance. Is the rule of law an essentially contested concept in florida. The rule of law does not have a precise definition, and its meaning can vary between different. All the things should be done according to a law not as per whim. The history and evolution of this concept shows that it has. The rule of law in india upendra baxi abstract the author underscores that the patrimonial liberal rule of law rol discourse usually disregards alternative traditions. Rule of law definition pdf the 2011 rule of law handbook is dedicated to all those who promote the rule of law in the. Challenges to the rule of aw in africa 7 executive summary the workshop on challenges to the rule of law in africa took place on 12 april 2016 in pretoria, south africa.
It places this analysis against a background of more theoretical accounts of the idea of the rule of law, drawing in ideas of political. Equality before the law and equal protection of the law. There is no doubt that the rule of law principle has been recognized as a milestone of modern democratic societies all around the world. This short essay is structured in the following manner. The concept of law hla hart, herbert lionel adolphus. The rule of law is one amongst a number of principles that are together regarded as undergirding the eu polity and common to the eu member states. What is the difference between rule by law and rule of. It means in the first place, the absolute supremacy or predominance of regular law as opposed to the influence of. Undemocratic nations that do not respect human rights commonly operate under a rule of law. Rule of law operations are conceptually difficult and hard to. It was discussed by ancient greek philosophers such as plato and aristotle around 350 bc. The rule of law refers to various established legal principles imposing limitations on governmental authority. The concept of rule of law is that the state is governed, not by the ruler or the. In particular, it focuses upon two major divisions within the law, namely the divisions between public and private laws and between substantive and procedural laws.
The rule of law requires that people should be governed by accepted rules, rather than by the. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Those are rules of law, but the rule of law is one of the ideals of our political. First published in 1961, it is considered the masterpiece of h.
As with all concepts, the rule of law has a history and one of the features of that history is the manner in which the concept has been reinterpreted over time. As a consequence of this, a very undemocratic nation or one without respect for human rights can exist with or without a rule of law, a situation which many argue is applicable to several modern. Sa law can be traced back to roman law, romandutch law and english law. Roman law 753 bc to 568 ad from this we still have the corpus iuris civilis a codification of roman law as an authoritative source of rl in sa courts today. Whether the analysis of the rule of law is limited to the consideration of its procedural aspects or is widened to include the consideration of political morality, reciprocity has a part to play. In another, it means that no government or its officials can enforce laws that are. See concise encyclopedia of western philosophy and philosophers 200 ed. The latter phrase is used to designate some particular legal rule like the rule against perpetuities or the rule that says we have to file our taxes by a certain date. The concept of rule of law is the building block on which the modern democratic society is founded. One is not concerned about what the law is or what its purpose is. Jul 19, 2014 in fact, it consists of many fields of law that sometimes exhibit large differences. What is the difference between rule by law and rule of law. In fact, i have found this volume used by both civilian and military rule of law practitioners from many agencies across afghanistan. In the earlier posts idea of law and definition of law, we talked about the idea of law and the various definitions and connotations attached to law.
The concept and the rule of law thousands of other examples could be cited. But, in such countries, rule of law does not exist. Fifty years on from its original publication, hla harts the concept of law is widely recognized as the most important work of legal philosophy published in the twentieth century. Is the rule of law an essentially contested concept in. The notion of rule of law preeminence du droit, together with those of pluralistic democracy and human rights, represents a fundamental principle and a common european value recognised in, inter alia, in the statute of the council of europe and the case law of the european court of human rights. Concept definition there is no single and commonly accepted definition of the rule of law i. It is a classic book in the field of legal scholarship and remains the starting point for most students coming to the subject for the first time. Shklar, political theory and the rule of law, in the rule of. It is one of a cluster of ideals constitutive of modern political morality, the others being human rights, democracy, and perhaps also the principles of free market economy. The concept of justice differs from the rule of law.
Applicability of the rule of law in tz jamiiforums. For the successful functioning of the polity it is imperative that there is enforcement of law and of all contracts based on law. First, it does not permit any reflection on the normative socialist rol conceptions. The florida debacle there was something for everyone in the events surrounding the counting and recounting of ballots in florida in the 2000 u. Rule of law law and legal definition according to the philosophy of rule of law, the law of the land is supreme over the acts of the government as well as private persons and the relationship between the state and the individual are regulated by the law of the land. The rule of law and protection from arbitrary power 8 12 17 20 22 1.
The phrase the rule of law has to be distinguished from the phrase a rule of law. In terms of section 3 of the constitution on founding. Harts enormous contribution to the study of jurisprudence and legal philosophy. The rule of law is a term that is often used but difficult to define. Oct 25, 2012 it is a classic book in the field of legal scholarship and remains the starting point for most students coming to the subject for the first time. Rule of law signifies a legalpolitical regime to protect the rights of citizens from arbitrary and abusive use of government power. The principle of reciprocity is therefore integral to the rule of law concept in both rulebook theories and in rightsbased theories.